You probably tried on the Dansko "Professional" clogs? Did you know that Dansko also makes lace up shoes. I also have a high arch but the clogs are super comfortable for me. You can maybe go to
www.zappos.com and check out the wide variety of Dansko shoes for men. You may also want to do a search for a brand called "Drew". They make a similar sole and also a rocker bottom.
PS Zappos has free delivery and a 365 day free return policy! You can't beat that!
Good luck.