Hi Shelly,
You can't argue with what feels best.
The three things that seem to help my patients are (1) a rigid shank and (2) a metatarsal pad (3) a wide enough shoe. So it's not so much the brand name of the shoe, it's more about trying to incorporate those characteristics of the shoe into what you're wearing.
First brand that does come to mind is Birkenstock. Birk's have a big met pad and a rigid shank. Most are made wide. And they're not all just sandals. I have on a pair of Birkenstocks today that are a buck suede leather lace up Oxford.
The width of the shoe does matter. Perhaps that's why the flip flops seem to feel better?
Jeff
